YOU KNEW HE'D GET TO AN INSIGHT EVENTUALLY:

 I recently asked a secular, liberal Egyptian from Cairo who was involved in the uprising against Hosni Mubarak whether the current regime feels like a return of the old order. "Oh, no," he said. "This one is far more brutal, repressive and cynical than Mubarak's." On Monday, Egypt's president, Abdel Fatah al-Sissi, issued a decree allowing the trial of more civilians in military courts. [...]

[T]arek Masoud , the author of a fascinating new book on Islamists and elections titled "Counting Islam," suggests that Tunisia's success and Egypt's failure have less to do with the qualities of its Islamists than with deep differences in those countries' political environments. In Egypt, Masoud argues, Islamists were able to defeat secular parties in the first elections after Mubarak was deposed because they could piggyback on the country's rich network of mosques and Islamic associations to reach everyday citizens. Secular parties didn't have anything equivalent. And so, after losing election after election, they turned to the army to overturn the results of the ballot box.

Tunisia was a different story, Masoud says. More developed, more urban, more literate and more globalized than Egypt, Tunisia had a more diverse civil society than Egypt's -- stronger labor unions, civic associations, professional groups -- so there was relative parity between Islamists and their opponents. Though Islamists did well in Tunisia's first elections, so did non-Islamists. Ennahda won only a plurality in the country's first freely elected legislature -- far less than the majority won by Islamist parties in Egypt -- and had to govern in coalition with two secular parties. It shared power not because it was nicer than the Muslim Brotherhood but because it had to. And Ennahda's opponents stuck with the democratic game even after losing, instead of calling on the army, because they, unlike the Egyptian secular parties, rightly felt they had a chance of winning in the future -- as they did this week. (Tunisia is fortunate in that its army has always been subordinate to civilian authority.)

Follow @brothersjudd