August 10, 2014

ALL ANGLOSPHERIC POLITICS IS THE SAME:

Would a citizen's income be better than our benefits system? : Phasing out tax relief and allowances may reduce the budget deficit while also adapting to the growing informal economy (Larry Elliott, 8/10/14, The Guardian)

One radical suggestion is for everybody to receive a citizen's income. Under this scheme, waged and unwaged, children and adults, the working aged and pensioner, rich and poor alike would receive the same basic income financed by the phasing out of virtually every tax relief and allowance. Those on benefits would not face high marginal tax rates if they took a job, but merely pay PAYE at the current standard rate of 20% on every pound they earned. Those working 20 hours a week on the minimum wage could work 40 hours a week without losing more than 50% of their extra earnings in lost tax credits.

There would be other advantages from such a system. First, it would be universal and hence avoid the stigma attached to benefits. Secondly, people taking a job or starting a business would have the security of knowing that they would still have their citizen's income if the venture did not work out.

Concerns that a citizen's income would encourage the idle to sit at home all day watching daytime TV do not appear to be supported by evidence from pilot schemes in other countries. Even so, there would be cases where this did happen and they would doubtless be highlighted as an example of a something-for-nothing culture. Other drawbacks include the failure so far to construct a citizen's income that obviates the need for housing benefit, and the political difficulty in persuading voters that a millionaire should be getting the same citizen's income as a milkman.

So far support for a citizen's income is limited to the Green party, although the government's switch to a flat-rate state pension is a step in that direction. The truth is that no tax and benefit system is perfect. But the one we have is costly, bureaucratic, ineffective - and ripe for reform.

It's Milton Friedman's world; we just live in it.

Posted by at August 10, 2014 9:26 PM
  
blog comments powered by Disqus
« JOBS WHITE PEOPLE WON'T DO: | Main | ALL THAT'S LEFT IS ACCEPTING THE LIFTING OF THE BLOCKADE: »