February 9, 2014
LET US, FOR THE SAKE OF ARGUMENT, TAKE CAPITALISM SERIOUSLY FOR A MOMENT...:
Leaving Work Behind (Ross Douthat, FEB. 8, 2014, NY Times)
[I]t's also possible to argue that as a rich, post-scarcity society, we shouldn't really care that much about whether the poor choose to work. The important thing is just making sure they have a decent standard of living, full stop, and if they choose Keynesian leisure over a low-paying job, that's their business.There are hints of a division within the liberal mind on this issue. Across the left and center-left, there's agreement that an unequal society requires a thicker social safety net, and that as technological changes undercut low-wage work, government should help those left behind.But in the Obamacare debate and elsewhere, it's not always clear whether this larger welfare state is supposed to promote a link between work, security and mobility, or to substitute for work's gradual decline. On the left, there's a growing tendency toward both pessimism and utopianism -- with doubts about the compatibility of capitalism and democracy, and skepticism about the possibility for true equality of opportunity, feeding a renewed interest in 1970s-era ideas like a universal basic income.On the conservative side, things are somewhat clearer. There are libertarians who like the basic income idea, but only as a substitute for the existing welfare state, not as a new expansion. Both "rugged individualist" right-wingers and more communitarian conservatives tend to see work as essential to dignity, mobility and social equality, and see its decline as something to be fiercely resisted.
...in which case, the argument that we should get rid of the division of labor and replace it with grossly inefficient labor (labor that is undignified by its very nature), because we can't accept alternative means of distributing wealth, can not be called a position of the right. It is the replacement of capitalism/conservatism with a punitive ideology.
Posted by Orrin Judd at February 9, 2014 11:27 AM