December 16, 2012
THE SHOOTING THAT MATTERED:
Russell Kirk on Malcolm X (Russell Kirk, Imaginative Conservative)
Inconsistent and erratic though many of his remarks were in recent months, Malcolm X may have been working his way toward some program less crazy than that of the Black Muslims he left--and who seem to have wreaked their vengeance upon him. He despised the sentimental American liberal of the sort that patronizes the Negro, and his first principle was that the Negro must work out his own improvement.In time, his talents for leadership, and the fact that his very notoriety compelled him to think about what he said, might have converted him gradually from fanatic utterance to reasonable courses. The man had more in him than simple hatred.Had Malcolm X been born in the modern black Africa with which he proposed American Negro solidarity, in this time of troubles he might have gone straight to the top; for he had the intelligence and the zeal and the self-confidence which give men power in revolutionary eras. He might then have risen to the dignity of president or premier; but then, too, he might have died at the hands of assassins, as still more African politicians will die before this year is out.In America, he was a freak; in 'emergent' Africa, he would have been a statesman. In Africa, after all, 'separation' of the races is a possibility; but to have separate Negro commonwealth in which Malcolm X professed to believe never could be realized in America.Our Chicago meeting was not acrimonious, and I should have liked to talk to Malcolm X longer, to ascertain if truly there was forever a great gulf fixed between us. But that unquiet spirit will not be heard again.
While MLK was a spent force by the time of his death and had wandered off into what would have been damaging economic and foreign policy byways, Brother Malcolm had just become truly interesting and his ideas stood to genuinely improve the lot of black Americans.Posted by Orrin Judd at December 16, 2012 7:25 AM
« WHICH IS HOW NATIVISM TRIGGERED THE CREDIT CRUNCH IN THE FIRST PLACE: | Main | RULE #1--NO POLITICS ON YOUR FACEBOOK PAGE: »