May 13, 2010

A GOOD ENOUGH FIRST STEP...:

Immigration and IDs: A Modest Proposal: All Americans—whether brown, white, or black—should be required to carry a passport showing they are red, white, and blue. (Christopher Dickey, May 13, 2010, Newsweek)

As it happens, when I was in Arizona for a conference last month I carried my passport everywhere I went. Not that I really expected to be asked for it: I was born in Tennessee and my Scots-Irish, English, German, and Danish forebears got me an exemption from such tribulations, even in Arizona, simply because they were all white. The fact is, I always carry my passport. After years living and working in Europe, the Middle East, and Central America, I've grown used to the idea that cops can ask me for my "papers" any time they choose.

In police states, this is a pretty ugly process—most often an attempt at intimidation, or extortion, or both. In democracies, it can be pretty ugly, too, and sometimes for the same reasons. But you get used to it, and if we're serious about drawing lines against illegal immigration—which is all about defining who is a card-carrying American and who is not—a national ID is the obvious first step. Without it, we're left guessing who "looks like" or "sounds like" a bona fide gringo.

So, to be fair, my modest proposal is that all Americans inside America, not just outside, should be required to have passports and to carry them at all times. Whenever any American is asked for an ID, he or she should have to produce one issued by the federal government.


...but the second obviously needs to be checkpoints where authorities would require everyone to show their passport.

Posted by Orrin Judd at May 13, 2010 3:29 PM
blog comments powered by Disqus
« AMERICAN MAN: | Main | GIVEN ITS POSITION ON THE FRONTLINE OF THE ARAB WORLD...: »