March 20, 2009

BUT CAN EVEN THE PASHTUN GOVERN PASHTUNISTAN?:

Obama's Afghan Struggle (FOUAD AJAMI, 3/20/09, WSJ)

The Afghan struggle was in truth a rod to be held up in the face of the Bush administration's quest in Iraq. Some months ago, Democratic Party strategist Robert Shrum owned up to this fact. "I was part of the 2004 Kerry campaign which elevated the idea of Afghanistan as the 'right war' to conventional Democratic wisdom. This was accurate as criticism, but also reflexive and perhaps by now even misleading as policy."
[Obama's Afghan Struggle] Getty Images

The opponents of the American project in Iraq did not know much about Afghanistan. They despaired of Iraq's sectarianism and ethnic fragmentation, but those pale in comparison with the tribalism and ethnic complications of Afghanistan. If you had your fill with the Kurds and the Sunnis and the Shiites of Iraq, welcome to the warring histories of the Pashtuns, the Uzbeks, the Tajiks, and the Hazara Shiites of Afghanistan.

In their disdain for that Iraq project, the Democrats and the liberal left had insisted that Iraq was an artificial state put together by colonial fiat, and that it was a fool's errand to try to make it whole and intact. Now in Afghanistan, we are in the quintessential world of banditry and tribalism, a political culture that has abhorred and resisted central authority.

Speak of colonial fiat: It was the Pax Britannica that drew the Durand Line of 1892 across the lands of the Pashtuns and marked out a meaningless border between Afghanistan and Pakistan. It should have taken no great literacy in the theories and the history of "state-building" to foresee the favorable endowments of Iraq and the built-in disadvantages of Afghanistan.


The brutal truth is that if tribalism makes Pashtunistan ungovernable then arming the tribes so they can concentrate on killing each other is a viable option for the rest of the world.

Posted by Orrin Judd at March 20, 2009 5:14 PM
blog comments powered by Disqus
« IT'S BAD ENOUGH HE'S STILL OBSESSED...: | Main | HE DOES FOREIGN POLICY LIKE HE BOWLS: »