AND THEY WONDER WHY WE DON'T TRUST THE MEDIA?

The Trial of John Kerry (William Rivers Pitt, 10 December 2003, t r u t h o u t)

There are but a few weeks to go before the Iowa caucuses and the New Hampshire primary. Time has grown short. In an effort to galvanize the message Kerry wants to deliver in the time remaining, he convened a powerful roster of journalists and columnists in the New York City apartment of Al Franken last Thursday. The gathering could not properly be called a meeting or a luncheon. It was a trial. The journalists served as prosecuting attorneys, jury and judge. The crowd I joined in Franken's living room was comprised of:

     Al Franken and his wife Franni;
     Rick Hertzberg, senior editor for the New Yorker;
     David Remnick, editor for the New Yorker;
     Jim Kelly, managing editor for Time Magazine;
     Howard Fineman, chief political correspondent for Newsweek;
     Jeff Greenfield, senior correspondent and analyst for CNN;
     Frank Rich, columnist for the New York Times;
     Eric Alterman, author and columnist for MSNBC and the Nation;
     Art Spiegelman, Pulitzer Prize winning cartoonist/author of "Maus";
     Richard Cohen, columnist for the Washington Post;
     Fred Kaplan, columnist for Slate;
     Jacob Weisberg, editor of Slate and author;
     Jonathan Alter, senior editor and columnist for Newsweek;
     Philip Gourevitch, columnist for the New Yorker;
     Calvin Trillin, freelance writer and author;
     Edward Jay Epstein, investigative reporter and author;
     Arthur Schlesinger, Jr., who needs no introduction.

We sat in a circle around Kerry and grilled him for two long hours. In an age of retail politicians who avoid substance the way vampires avoid sunlight, in an age when the sitting President flounders like a gaffed fish whenever he must speak to reporters without a script, Kerryís decision to open himself to the slings and arrows of this group was bold and impressive. He was fresh from two remarkable speeches -- one lambasting the PATRIOT Act, another outlining his foreign policy ideals while eviscerating the Bush record ñ and had his game face on. He needed it, because Eric Alterman lit into him immediately on the all-important issue of his vote for the Iraq War Resolution. The prosecution had begun.

Remember the outrage twenty years ago when George Will, a mere columnist, helped Ronald Reagan prepare for a debate with Jimmy Carter? Look at all the freakin' editors on this list.

Posted by Orrin Judd at March 22, 2004 10:43 PM