March 1, 2007

WHEN GEOLOGY BECOMES VICTIMOLOGY (via brian boys):

Scientists probe 'hole in Earth' (BBC, 2/28/07)

Scientists are to sail to the mid-Atlantic to examine a massive "open wound" on the Earth's surface.

Dr Chris MacLeod, from Cardiff University, said the Earth's crust appeared to be completely missing in an area thousands of kilometres across.


As Brother Boys points out, it's entirely typical that they have no clue what it is or what caused it yet speak about it as if it were our fault--a "wound" and such. It's the ironically characteristic conceit of the "scientific" who claim on the one hand that Man is nothing special but on the other ascribe him with nearly unlimited power and a central place in the Universe.

Posted by Orrin Judd at March 1, 2007 8:43 PM
Comments

The anthropomorphic language is odd in this context, but nowhere in the article does it remotely suggest that humans are at fault...

Posted by: Anthony Perez-Miller at March 1, 2007 9:04 PM

Agreed.

But discoveries of massive anomolies like this just now indicate just how little we know about the Earth after millennia of exploration. Yet we have concluded we're running out of oil and have caused cataclysmic climate change as OJ points out frequently.

For all we know, there's a huge oil deposit right next to the hole and a bunch of carbon eating algae floating over it but it might take us another century to find them.

Posted by: JAB at March 1, 2007 10:07 PM

This article is so typical of so much scientific reporting in the popular press: inexact and muddled and riddled with terms used inmproperly and lacking in hard facts with opinions and subjectivity substituted. They can't even provide a simple map to show where the "wound" is located. Sheeh. Besides, "the crust does not seem to be repairing itself" talk doesn't explain what is there that makes it so unusual. Surely they can spend at least one paragraph on that.

Sounds like it may be simply a deeper than usual part of the spreading zone, or some sort of reverse-Iceland, where the activity is much lower than normal. And I don'[t get the deal about serpentinite, which is quite common along the San Andreas rift sone in Marin County, for example. (At least if I remember my geology field trips from decades ago...)

Posted by: Raoul Ortega at March 2, 2007 12:07 AM

As Brother Boys points out, it's entirely typical that they have no clue what it is or what caused it yet speak about it as if it were our fault--a "wound" and such.

You all aren't very clear on the concepts of metaphor or simile are you?

Posted by: BtC at March 2, 2007 5:45 AM

Actually BtC not only are we clear on similes and metaphors, we eat them for breakfast with organically grown raisins.

We're also very clear about the nature of media reportage. No matter the tenuous connection, every story is slanted to imply that we (American) humans are destroying mother earth by our reckless behavior using up all her resources to advance our hedonistic life styles which are causing the seas to rise, the mountains to fall and on and on.

I have to stop now, I feel dizzy and have to take a prescription drug which George W. Bush conspiring with evil drug corporations made available to us old geezers at a ridiculously low price passing the real costs on to younger workers who won't get a cent of the social security they paid into and to make matters worse, these drugs aren't made available to those dying of AIDS in primitive villages in equatorial Africa or those dying of malaria because they have been also been deprived of DDT and ... and ...

kerplunk.

Posted by: erp at March 2, 2007 7:45 AM

of science, not reporting.

Posted by: oj at March 2, 2007 7:46 AM

Who "wounded" it? Mars in a playground fight?

Posted by: oj at March 2, 2007 7:51 AM

BtC:

Bingo! Scientific paradigms are mere metaphors.

Posted by: oj at March 2, 2007 9:06 AM

Yes, Rove's earthcrust wounding machine is being used to tear a gash earth's crust. Notice that he hasn't been seen or heard from lately?

Posted by: Dave W at March 2, 2007 11:07 AM
« THEY DON'T HATE THE SYMBOL, THEY HATE THE WORD ITSELF: | Main | IF ONLY OUR INTELLIGENCE SERVICES PARTOOK OF ANY: »