October 3, 2005

MAKING THE TRAINS RUN ON TIME...OKAY, RUN AT ALL...:

Can Hamas change course?: Some in the group want to focus more on politics and less on attacking Israel. (Ilene R. Prusher, 10/04/05, The Christian Science Monitor)

The results in Beitunia are remarkable in several ways. Even though Fatah, led by Palestinian president Mahmoud Abbas, won the largest number of seats in about half of the 104 municipal councils that were being chosen last week, in many places, the wins were not enough for Fatah to claim leadership. That resembles the situation next door, in Israel's multiparty system, in which neither of the two main parties has won a majority in recent years, and must go into negotiations with small parties who suddenly hold the power to make or break a coalition.

What's more, Shalabi represents what could be the face of Hamas's future. At least in some camps, there's an attempt to reshape Hamas, which won 13 municipalities in the vote, as a Muslim political party and less of a guerrilla group. But the different faces of Hamas - ranging from technocrats like Shalabi to a military wing that continues to attack Israelis - may make Hamas as political party a hard sell to the rest of the world.


The rest of the world doesn't matter--with nationhood in hand, both Fatah and Hamas have to convince Palestinians they can govern effectively.

Posted by Orrin Judd at October 3, 2005 6:20 PM
Comments

[B]oth Fatah and Hamas have to convince Palestinians they can govern effectively.

Hopefully.

While democracy is a pretty effective way to ensure, over the long run, that the most effective people are in power, elections alone cannot guarantee that anyone WILL be effective at leading.

Italy since WW II is a pretty good example of that.

Posted by: Michael Herdegen [TypeKey Profile Page] at October 3, 2005 7:58 PM

Italy:

GDP - per capita: $27,700 (2004 est.)

England:

GDP - per capita: $29,600 (2004 est.)

Posted by: oj at October 3, 2005 8:27 PM

Palestinians have a similar GDP - if you count the US & EU contributions to their budget. (100%, I believe)

Posted by: obc at October 3, 2005 9:11 PM

Where the weakness of Italian political leadership hurts is specifically in the Mezzogiorno - the boot and Sicily. Northern Italy, historically part of the old Holy Roman Empire and incubators of the Renaissance, has always done well. But southern Italy was constantly shuffled between the Byzantines, Arabs, Normans, French, and Spanish until Italian unification and never developed. That area continues to suck from the Italian state like a vampire. It's the reason people like Umberto Bossi wants Northern Italy to be a separate country.

Posted by: Chris Durnell at October 4, 2005 11:58 AM
« PRIVILEGED: | Main | THINGS HAVEN'T BEEN THIS BAD SINCE THE 90s: »